Monday 9 November 2015

What is Bending moment and Shear force in Laymen's term?

SHEAR FORCE


Take a few books. Place them next to each other contiguously. Now lift them by pressing the books on both the extreme ends as shown in picture below.

Image credit: live at your local

What is preventing the books in between from falling off the stack? Obviously there has to be some force that is acting upward which is preventing the fall. Also, how is the weight of the books transferred between each of the books and finally to your hand? 

The answer is obviously friction which is a vertical force generated at the interface between books, induced by the horizontal force applied by your hand. I've separated the books and shown the forces acting on them (free body diagram) in the figure below. Now, obviously, the total downward force should cancel out the total upward force, otherwise the books would be bouncing up and down out of your hands. I have hidden the horizontal force (which is the main cause for friction) for clarity purposes, only vertical frictional forces are shown. For simplicity, weight of the books are considered to be point load acting at the center. 

Assume four books each weighing 1 kg, so the total downward force (due to gravity) = 4 kg (not using 'Newton' for simplicity.) To resist this downward force, the frictional upward force generated by both your hands = 4 kg i.e. upward frictional force generated at each hand is 4/2 = 2 kg. Let's proceed from left toward right to plot the vertical forces acting on the books.

Free body diagram of books. Proceed from left to right to see the forces cancelling each other. 

Now, if I were to make a diagram of the vertical forces and call it a Frictional Force Diagram (FFD) it would look something like this. 


A simplified frictional force diagram. 

Now the concept of Shear Force is "kind of" similar to the frictional force explained above. Consider a simple beam as shown in the figure below. Now, instead of books, imagine an infinite number sections throughout the length of the beam. Whenever the beam is loaded, each section tries to slip against its adjacent section, resulting in deformation of the section. The deformation produces a resisting force which prevents the slipping of the section, this force is called the shear force. Sections near supports are trying to slip further from each other compared to the sections near the center. Hence evidently more shear force is developed at the supports (see the force diagram above) than at the center. This is how the loads are transferred onto the supports. 

The loads on the first floor of your house viz., weights of people, furniture, etc., are transferred to the beams through shear force developed in the slab, the beams in turn transfer them to columns again through shear force, the column then transfers the load to the footing by simple axial force and the footing spreads the loads safely over a very large area on the ground.

A diagram depicting the shear forces at all the sections is called shear force diagram which is similar to the one plotted above. Please note that I have presented a simple loading condition. Structures in real-life are subject to more complex loading patterns and shear force diagrams will be very different.

Image credit: dlsweb.rmit.edu.au
Image credit: staffweb.itsligo.ie/

A shear failure happens at a section when the shear stress (= shear force divided by sectional area) developed at that section is greater than the shear strength of the material i.e. the maximum permissible shear stress. Civil engineers calculate these shear stresses and design the buildings so that the stresses are well within the materials' shear capacity. Mechanical engineers ensure the same in machines. That photo frame hanging on your wall has not fallen down yet because the shear stresses induced by the weight of the photo frame is less than the shear strength of the screw/nail. Some shear failure pictures are shown below. 

Notice how shear failure has occurred at the support, which is the location of maximum shear stress. (Image credit: fhwa.dot.gov) (Note: Shear failure need not always happen at the location of max shear stress. It happens when shear stress at a section is greater than shear strength of that section. Shear strength is not the same at all sections.)

Shear failure of soil (Image credit: riverpartners.org)


Image credit: slidesharecdn.com  

Phew! I hope the explanation is clear to a layman. I'm a bit tired now. Will add the bending moment part later, hope you don't mind.

What is the role of bundle bars in column?

Bundling of bars becomes necessary when large number of bars are required to be accommodated in a structural member. Concrete codes dictate minimum criteria for spacing of the reinforcing bars to ensure that during construction fresh concrete can be placed easily in between and around the bars. Therefore, when there are large number of bars required to be provided based on design, it may not be possible to place the bars separately with necessary clearance. In such cases, there are two options:
  1. Increase the size of the member (columns, beams).
  2. Bundle the bars in groups of two, three or four bars.
However, option 1 means unnecessary cost implications due to the increase in the volume of concrete. Hence, engineers mostly resort to bundling of bars.
Image credit: http://civcal.media.hku.hk/

It is important to note that bundled bars have low contact area with the surrounding concrete when compared to the bars placed separately. This affects the bonding between concrete and the rebars which is of concern especially in beams. To compensate this, the development length is increased suitably and curtailment, wherever prescribed, is done at different points for each bar. 

The development length of each bar of bundled bars shall be that for the individual bar, increased by 10 percent for two bars in contact, 20 percent for three bars in contact and 33 percent for four bars in contact.

-- Clause 26.2.1.2, Code 456-2000, Bureau of Indian Standards.

How does increase in water cement ratio decrease the permeability of concrete?


Increase in w/c ratio from 0.4 to 0.7, increases the permeability by nearly four orders of magnitude i.e. from 10^(-12) cm/s to 10^(-8) cm/s.*

This is because of two primary reasons:
1. Formation of high capillary porosity from large and well-connected pores. 
2. Increase in micro cracks at the interfacial transition zone between aggregate and cement paste that are induced by drying shrinkage (which is again directly linked with the w/c ratio). The diagrammatic representation of interfacial transition zone between aggregate and cement paste is shown below.

(Image credit: Concrete, Microstructure and Properties by Mehta and Monteiro.)

All said and done, concrete is batshit crazy material. Its behaviour is not understood completely by us. We can only improve our knowledge based on new empirical observations and findings.

*Values for hardened cement paste only.
*Data source: Powers, T.C., J. Am. Ceram. Soc. ,Vol. 4, No. 1, pp. 1–5, 1958.